18 February 2020   The Moral Devastation of the Continued Occupation (1/2) - By: Alon Ben-Meir

12 February 2020   The Travesty of the Century - By: Alon Ben-Meir

9 February 2020   Blueprint for Palestine - By: Dr. Noha Khalaf

5 February 2020   Trump’s and Netanyahu’s Folly - By: Alon Ben-Meir

4 February 2020   Duh, Jared! So who built the PA as a ‘police state’? - By: Jonathan Cook

30 January 2020   Trump’s Dreadful Foreign Policy - By: Alon Ben-Meir

28 January 2020   A recipe for endless oppression and injustice - By: Rev. Dr. Mae Elise Cannon

5 أيلول 2015   "من الأزل".. آخر كتب الراحل جونتر جراس - بقلم: المركز الألماني للإعلام (ألمانيا إنفو/ almania info)

18 April 2019

Palestine is not for sale and baseball arbitration will not work

By: Daoud Kuttab
print     send by email

One of the biggest problems that US President Donald Trump’s administration has faced is that it constantly looks for solutions from the business world, with the idea that money can solve any problem. Trump wants to apply real estate answers to complication problems, such as America’s immigration problem. Ban Muslims, build a wall and stop foreign aid to central American governments and the problem will go away.

Trump’s team of real estate and bankruptcy lawyers think the same way in trying to solve the Palestinian-Israeli conflict simply by throwing money at the problem and expecting it to be resolved.

Realising that many have tried and failed to resolve the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, the team, headed by Trump’s son-in-law Jared Kushner, has apparently came up with a creative plan, again taken from the world of American business, namely baseball arbitration.

Baseball arbitration is defined as “a type of arbitration in which each party to the arbitration submits a proposed monetary award to the arbitrator. After a final hearing, the arbitrator will choose one award from the submitted awards without modification”.

The idea behind baseball arbitration came as a result of the constant fights between players and owners about the salary, especially of superstar players. Not wanting the players to enter a costly strike, the idea behind this arbitration is that it forces both sides to make reasonable suggestions of the dollar amount that they can live with, knowing full well that they are dealing with a totally neutral arbitrator that will chose the most reasonable offer.

The idea reminds me of a childhood principle we used to apply when were children and had to divide between ourselves a banana or a piece of cake. To ensure that the division is fair, the principle was that one side divides and the other side chooses. So, the side dividing has to be careful that the division is so fair that it would not matter which part our sibling chose to take.

Demanding, even forcing, both sides to come to the table with a compromise offer that does not accomplish all their goals, yet at the same time is reasonable, is a great idea that must be pursued. It makes sense that a compromise offer made by any party will have a much bigger opportunity to be implemented than one forced down the party’s throat.

While the need for a formula to unlock the decades-long jam is badly needed, one has to wonder how the US suggestion of using baseball arbitration that lacks mutual agreement, and, most important, includes a biased arbitrator, would work. If compromises are to be offered, both parties must first agree on the process, and secondly agree on the arbitrator.

It is true that the Palestinian leadership held numerous meetings with the Trump administration in its first months, but ever since the unilateral American decision of moving the US embassy to Jerusalem was announced, and later implemented, Washington and the Trump administration lost even the appearance of neutrality in trying to find an acceptable solution.

The public has not been privy to what went on in the Palestinian meetings with the Trump team, but it is safe to assume that no agreement on a process, such as baseball arbitration, or any other kind of logjam-breaking idea, has been agreed upon.

Ever since the US embassy’s move and the Palestinian decision to boycott the Americans, what the public has seen has been a set of punitive acts that has caused real hardships to the Palestinian people. Defunding UNRWA, stopping aid to Jerusalem hospitals that treat pediatric cancer patients, ending all USAID support for Palestinian infrastructure, closing the Palestinian diplomatic mission in Washington and passing legislation that makes the Palestinian government vulnerable to American courts have removed any effort to try and present American diplomacy as an honest broker.

Baseball arbitration might work fine in deciding how much to pay star players in America, but is not a formula that can work in a struggle involving people, land and a long history of conflict and bloodshed.

Palestinians and Israelis must have the courage to offer reasonable compromises that they can live with, but this can only happen in an environment that welcomes such compromises and ensures that nothing is agreed until everything is agreed. For Israelis, or for that matter Palestinians, to pocket a compromise made by the other side and use that as a starting point for talks is the opposite of a reasonable negotiating process.

If the team of Jared Kushner, Jason Greenblatt and David Friedman are serious about trying to resolve the conflict, they need to shed aside any bias seen or acted upon, bring with them other international partners and roll up their sleeves and work with both sides to find that elusive compromise solution that no one likes but that both sides can live with.

The Palestinian-Israeli conflict cannot be solved by throwing money at it. Palestine is not for sale. 

The conflict will also not be solved using business processes like baseball arbitration, especially when one team and the umpire appear to be on the same side.

Baseball and other sports succeed when both teams and the public trust that the umpires are neutral, act in a fair way and are seen to be acting fairly. This is not the case with the present Trump negotiating team.

* A Palestinian columnist based in Amman, Jordan. - dkuttab@ammannet.net

Security Code

19 شباط 2020   فلسطين ومهام المرحلة..! - بقلم: د. عبد الرحيم جاموس

19 شباط 2020   الشعب الفلسطيني الحاضر الأبدي..! - بقلم: عمر حلمي الغول

19 شباط 2020   مؤتمر ميونيخ للأمن 2020.. ما الذي يشغل الغرب؟! - بقلم: د. أماني القرم

18 شباط 2020   الفكر الصهيوني لا مكان فيه للسلام..! - بقلم: د. عبد الرحيم جاموس

18 شباط 2020   الضم.. في صندوق الاقتراع الصهيوني - بقلم: محمد أبو شريفة

18 شباط 2020   عقدة المحرقة تطاردها..! - بقلم: عمر حلمي الغول

18 شباط 2020   لماذا تأجل الضم؟! - بقلم: شاكر فريد حسن

17 شباط 2020   بيني غانتس ليس بديلًا..! - بقلم: شاكر فريد حسن

17 شباط 2020   ماذا سَيَجنيِ المطبعون؟! - بقلم: د. عبد الرحيم جاموس

17 شباط 2020   بين التطبيع والمقاومة شعرة..! - بقلم: عمر حلمي الغول

31 كانون أول 2019   غزة 2020.. تحديات البقاء والمواجهة..! - بقلم: وسام زغبر

3 أيلول 2019   "بردلة".. انتزاع الحق بسواعد مكبلة..! - بقلم: اتحاد الجان العمل الزراعي

27 اّذار 2011   عداد الدفع المسبق خال من المشاعر الإنسانية..!! - بقلم: محمد أبو علان

13 شباط 2011   سقط مبارك فعادت لنا الحياة - بقلم: خالد الشرقاوي

4 شباط 2011   لا مستحيل..!! - بقلم: جودت راشد الشويكي

29 كانون ثاني 2020   فيئوا إليّ..! - بقلم: فراس حج محمد

27 كانون ثاني 2020   هل يمكن أن يكون الشعب فاسدا بناء على الروايات؟ - بقلم: فراس حج محمد

22 كانون ثاني 2020   ربع قرن على تأسيس "دار الأماني" للنشر - بقلم: شاكر فريد حسن

20 كانون ثاني 2020   مهرجان الدَّسْتَة العربي في عمّان..! - بقلم: راضي د. شحادة

8 كانون ثاني 2011   "صحافة المواطن" نافذة للأشخاص ذوي الاعاقة - بقلم: صدقي موسى

10 تشرين ثاني 2010   رساله .. - بقلم: جودت راشد الشويكي

3 تشرين ثاني 2010   شخبطة صحفية - بقلم: حسناء الرنتيسي

27 تشرين أول 2010   المدلل .. - بقلم: جودت راشد الشويكي

21 تشرين أول 2010   فضفضة مواطنية - بقلم: حسناء الرنتيسي

4 اّذار 2012   الطقش

26 كانون ثاني 2012   امرأة في الجفتلك


English | الصفحة الرئيسية | كاريكاتير | صحف ومجلات | أخبار وتقارير | اّراء حرة | الإرشيف | صوتيات | صحفيون وكتاب | راسلنا

جميع الحقوق محفوظة © لشبكة  أمين الأعلامية 2020- 1996 
تصميم وتطوير شبكة أمين الأعلامية